ATA proposes six steps after FMCSA revokes authorization for 133 ELDs
The trucking group wants independent certification, stronger fraud checks and continuing oversight of electronic logging devices. Its plan would build on current federal mechanisms while keeping FMCSA responsible for technical and enforcement work.

FMCSA revoked authorization for 133 ELDs in its latest action.1
Fleets cited for ELD tampering had a crash rate 56% higher than the comparison group, according to the cited safety alliance.2
ATA released its recommendations on Nov 16, including independent certification and a U.S.-based vendor requirement.2
Story
A proposed framework for ELD oversightThe American Trucking Associations has put forward six recommendations to address electronic logging device fraud, following FMCSA’s removal of authorization for 133 devices last week. (FreightWaves reported the revocations; Transport Topics reported the six-part proposal.)12 The plan would change how devices are approved and monitored, with independent certification and safeguards intended to detect manipulated records. (Transport Topics described the certification proposal; the fraud-check recommendations are reported by both outlets.)2 ATA’s stated aim is to rebuild confidence promptly in the ELD environment and preserve confidence over time in both the system and federal databases. (FreightWaves reported the goals set out in the ATA report.)1 The recent removals sit within a longer sequence: almost 300 ELD authorizations have been withdrawn since the Trump administration took office, compared with fewer than 200 during the Biden administration. (FreightWaves gives these totals for the two administrations.)1 Those figures describe revocations across each administration’s period in office, while the 133 devices refer to the latest group identified by FMCSA. (FreightWaves reports both measures.)1
The proposal responds to a system in which manufacturers currently certify their own ELDs against FMCSA requirements. (FreightWaves describes the existing approval process.)1 FMCSA has lately examined those self-certification submissions more closely than it did before, according to FreightWaves. (The report describes a change in the agency’s scrutiny.)1 ATA does not call for discarding all existing certification arrangements; it recommends that FMCSA use mechanisms already in place as the basis for improvement. (FreightWaves reports this recommendation.)1 One proposed route is for FMCSA to finance an accreditation system that qualifies outside organizations to certify devices. (FreightWaves describes the proposed role for third parties and federal funding.)1 Under that division of work, FMCSA would retain responsibility for technical matters and enforcement even as qualified organizations conduct certification. (FreightWaves reports the roles envisioned in the proposal.)1
ATA points to the 2022 ANPRM as a possible starting point for a later NPRM, which could test whether accreditation providers are interested. (FreightWaves describes the proposed use of the earlier notice.)1 The proposal also treats certification as an ongoing obligation rather than a check performed only once when a device enters the market. (FreightWaves reports that certification should continue for the device’s full lifecycle.)1 Transport Topics summarizes the remaining recommendations as strengthening fraud investigations, maintaining compliance after certification, and updating technical requirements regularly. (These are among the actions listed in its account of the ATA plan.)2 The reporting therefore describes certification as both an entry control and a continuing measure, with technical standards subject to periodic revision. (FreightWaves and Transport Topics report the relevant proposals.)12 This approach connects the proposed approval process to oversight after approval, rather than treating an initial certificate as sufficient evidence of lasting compliance. (The ATA recommendations call for lifecycle certification and sustained compliance.)12
ATA’s short-term recommendation is for FMCSA to confront known forms of fraud without waiting for a rulemaking process. (FreightWaves reports this proposed near-term action.)1 For the longer term, the group wants more points at which devices and their suppliers can be checked, increasing opportunities to find fraud. (FreightWaves describes the intended effect of that approach.)1 Fraudulent electronic records may contain file numbers that do not follow sequence, distances that cannot be physically achieved, or altered driver details. (FreightWaves lists these warning signs.)1 ATA proposes automated screening for those irregularities, followed by human review of records that trigger a flag. (Transport Topics describes the proposed combination of automated checks and staff review.)2 That design would use software to identify suspect patterns but would not make the automated flag the final review described in the recommendation. (Transport Topics says a person would examine flagged records.)2
One reported scheme involves a driver who has reached the hours-of-service limit calling a phone number to submit replacement logs. (FreightWaves describes this method.)1 The new records in that account falsely represent the driver as having more available hours than the original logs would show. (FreightWaves reports the alleged purpose of the upload.)1 The example illustrates why ATA’s plan addresses both record patterns and the people or businesses associated with the devices. (FreightWaves describes the method, while Transport Topics reports the vendor-accountability proposal.)12 ATA wants companies that register ELDs to demonstrate a verified presence in the United States. (Transport Topics reports this recommendation.)2 The stated purpose is to make those companies answerable to FMCSA and law enforcement. (Transport Topics gives that rationale for the U.S.-presence requirement.)2
Transport Topics reports that fleets cited for tampering with ELDs have a crash rate 56% above that of the comparison group, citing the Commercial Vehicle Safety Alliance. (The outlet reports the comparison.)2 The 56% figure compares crash rates for fleets cited for tampering with those of the comparison group described by the alliance. (Transport Topics attributes the statistic to the Commercial Vehicle Safety Alliance.)2 It is a rate comparison about fleets, not a count of crashes or of individual drivers. (The reported measure is a higher crash rate among cited fleets.)2 The recommendations also address the suppliers and registering companies behind devices, alongside the records produced during use. (Transport Topics reports the U.S.-presence requirement and record-screening measures.)2 Taken together, these proposals target device approval, ongoing compliance, suspicious data and the ability to hold vendors accountable. (Transport Topics and FreightWaves describe these parts of the ATA plan.)12
ATA’s Working Group on ELD Fraud was established by the association’s Safety Policy Committee last year. (Transport Topics reports the group’s origin.)2 The group’s recommendations include both immediate steps that do not require rulemaking and longer-range changes to certification and detection. (FreightWaves describes the short- and long-term proposals.)12 Transport Topics reports that Henry Hanscom commended FMCSA for taking an active approach to stronger vetting, oversight and the removal of bad actors. (The outlet attributes that assessment to Hanscom.)2 The plan thus acknowledges agency work already under way while calling for a more durable framework and additional checks. (Transport Topics reports Hanscom’s praise; FreightWaves describes the proposed framework and checks.)12 Kevin Grove described the next task as providing FMCSA with lasting means to safeguard ELD integrity and raise the difficulty and cost of cheating. (Transport Topics reports his account of the objective.)2
Transport Topics reported that ATA released its six recommendations on Nov 16, including independent certification and a requirement for U.S.-based vendors. (The outlet gives the release date and examples of the recommendations.)2 FreightWaves describes the certification proposal as drawing on many features of the Canadian system, while keeping FMCSA’s technical and enforcement functions in place. (The account covers both the model’s influence and the agency’s retained duties.)1 The Canadian approach is presented as a reference for designing a U.S. program, not as a claim that ATA proposes importing the entire system. (FreightWaves says the proposal follows many aspects of that system.)1 The combination of outside certification and federal responsibility is central to the proposed arrangement. (FreightWaves reports the proposed third-party role and FMCSA’s retained responsibilities.)1 The wider issue in the ATA report is whether device approvals and federal records can command trust while fraud controls are strengthened. (FreightWaves states the report’s trust goals and describes the proposed controls.)1
The immediate enforcement figures and the proposed structural changes describe different parts of the problem: revocations remove authorization, while certification and monitoring are intended to shape how devices are vetted and checked. (FreightWaves reports the revocations and ATA’s proposals.)12 ATA’s approach would combine a stronger approval path with continuing compliance, fraud investigation and revised technical requirements. (Transport Topics reports these recommendations.)2 Its near-term measures focus on known methods and suspicious records, while its longer-term proposals add more checks involving devices and suppliers. (FreightWaves describes the time horizons and their aims.)1 The figures cited in the coverage show the scale of recent authorization removals and an administration-by-administration comparison, while the crash statistic describes a separate association involving fleets cited for tampering. (The reports distinguish these counts and rate comparison.)12 The proposal’s central test, as presented by ATA, is whether the framework can support trust in ELDs and federal data while making fraud harder to carry out. (FreightWaves reports the trust objective; Transport Topics reports Grove’s description of the intended deterrent.)12
History
How it came to this- Last yearATA working group formedThe Safety Policy Committee created the Working Group on ELD Fraud.
- 2022Earlier notice identified as a possible basisATA says the ANPRM could provide a foundation for a future NPRM about accreditation providers.
- RecentlyFMCSA increased scrutinyThe agency began examining self-certification submissions more thoroughly than before.
- Last weekLatest device removalsFMCSA revoked authorization for 133 ELDs.
- Nov 16ATA released its recommendationsThe proposal included independent certification and a U.S.-based vendor requirement.
- Now133 ELD authorizations revoked in latest FMCSA action
- Future NPRMATA says the 2022 ANPRM could be a foundation for a future NPRM that gauges interest among accreditation providers; no date is specified.
Impact
Spreading outward, level by level- Level 1ELD approval
ATA proposes building on existing certification mechanisms and funding an accreditation program in which qualified outside organizations certify devices while FMCSA retains technical and enforcement duties.1
Fact - Level 2Device compliance over time
The recommendations treat certification as ongoing across a device’s lifecycle and call for sustained compliance and regular technical updates.12
Fact - Level 3Fraud detection
ATA calls for near-term action against known fraud methods and longer-term opportunities to check devices and suppliers; proposed automated flags would receive human review.12
Fact - Level 4Trust in ELDs and federal records
The proposal aims to restore short-term trust in the ELD environment and preserve confidence in the system and federal databases over time.1
Fact - Level 5Potential deterrence
If implemented as described, the combination of stronger certification, continuing checks, and vendor accountability could make fraudulent use harder to sustain.
Analysis
Ahead
Checked automatically when due; the result goes to the track recordATA says the 2022 ANPRM could be a foundation for a future NPRM that gauges interest among accreditation providers; no date is specified.
Sources
What each source supportsWritten by AI from the sources listed below: every fact was checked word for word against its source, and inference is marked apart. How we write