Judge rejects New Mexico bar authorities’ motions in SCRA licensing case
Judge Kea Riggs denied dismissal motions filed by the New Mexico Supreme Court and the New Mexico Board of Bar Examiners on November 19. The ruling identifies the state bodies as authorities covered by federal license-portability protections and addresses which admission checks those protections allow.
Judge Kea Riggs denied the dismissal motions filed by the New Mexico Supreme Court and the Board of Bar Examiners.1
The Justice Department describes this as its first action to enforce the SCRA’s professional-license portability provisions.1
Since 2011, the Department says its SCRA enforcement has secured more than this amount in monetary relief for over 153,000 servicemembers.1
Story
What the ruling says about military applicants and New Mexico bar licensingOn November 19, Judge Kea Riggs turned down dismissal requests from both the New Mexico Supreme Court and the New Mexico Board of Bar Examiners. The Justice Department describes the lawsuit as its first action seeking to enforce the Servicemembers Civil Relief Act’s professional-license portability rules. The decision includes a finding that both state bodies fall within the law’s category of licensing authorities. It also distinguishes a permitted criminal background check from a broader character-and-fitness review that the court says may not be imposed in this setting.1 The ruling concerns what the federal law permits licensing bodies to require of military applicants seeking to use its portability provision. The court’s stated distinction is not between checking an applicant’s background and doing no checking at all: it allows a criminal background inquiry while rejecting the more extensive evaluation normally used for first-time applicants. That difference matters to the dispute because the Department says New Mexico’s requirements go beyond what the statute allows. The denial of the motions is the reported court action; the alleged violations remain allegations described by the Department.1 According to the Department, New Mexico requires military applicants to submit transcripts, test scores and references, and to complete a full character-and-fitness assessment. The Department alleges that this package exceeds the permissions in the SCRA. The court’s ruling separately addresses the scope of permissible screening, stating that a criminal background check may be conducted but the usual expansive assessment for first-time applicants may not. These statements describe the disputed requirements and the court’s stated legal boundary; they do not establish that every listed requirement was individually assessed in the decision.1 The court also determined that the Department had alleged facts indicating a pattern or practice of violations by the New Mexico Supreme Court and the Board of Bar Examiners. That determination concerns the sufficiency and character of the allegations, as described in the Justice Department’s account. It is distinct from the finding that the two bodies are licensing authorities covered by the portability provision. Together, those rulings address who is covered and what kind of conduct the Department says it is challenging, without turning the Department’s allegations into a final determination that violations occurred.1
The underlying legal framework is the Servicemembers Civil Relief Act, which includes provisions for portability of professional licenses. The Justice Department says this lawsuit is its first-ever effort to enforce those particular provisions. That description places the case within the Department’s enforcement of the SCRA while identifying the professional-license rules as a new focus for its litigation. The Department also says the Act was enacted to reduce burdens associated with military service, rather than add to them.1 Acting Assistant Attorney General Craig Trainor made that point in the Department’s account of the case, describing the statute’s purpose as easing rather than increasing the demands connected with service. His statement supplies the Department’s explanation of why it is pursuing the licensing dispute. The court’s ruling, by contrast, supplies the findings about coverage and the boundary between background checks and the wider evaluation. Keeping those roles separate matters: the purpose statement is an official’s account, while the licensing conclusions are attributed to the court.1 The affected applicants described in the Department’s allegations are military applicants seeking New Mexico professional licenses under the portability provision. The state requirements the Department identifies include submitted records and references as well as a character-and-fitness process. The court’s stated allowance for criminal background checks means the ruling does not describe all screening as forbidden. Instead, the court differentiates that check from the more extensive evaluation normally applied to first-time applicants.1 The account does not provide a count of military applicants who have faced the identified requirements or a number of applications affected. It therefore describes the alleged practices and the court’s legal findings without quantifying their reach among applicants. The pattern-or-practice determination refers to facts alleged by the Department, not to a numerical measure of affected people in the supplied account. The only applicant groups expressly identified there are military applicants and, in the Department’s guidance, servicemembers and their dependents who believe their SCRA rights were violated.1
The Department’s Civil Rights Division enforces the SCRA through its Housing and Civil Enforcement Section working with U.S. Attorneys’ Offices. That enforcement structure is the institutional context for the lawsuit, which the Department presents as its first action focused on professional-license portability. The Department’s description links the case to an existing civil-rights enforcement function while noting the particular subject of this action. It does not provide a separate account of the investigation or explain how the complaint was developed.1 The Department reports that, since 2011, its SCRA enforcement has produced more than $490 million in monetary relief for over 153,000 servicemembers. Those figures describe the Department’s enforcement record across the period it identifies, rather than the number of people involved in the New Mexico licensing dispute. Monetary relief is the reported financial measure, while the servicemember figure counts people for whom relief was obtained. The supplied account does not say that either total represents outcomes in professional-licensing cases.1 The historical totals offer context for the Department’s broader SCRA work, but they do not determine the result of this lawsuit. The case is identified as the Department’s first attempt to enforce the Act’s professional-license portability protections, whereas the reported relief and servicemember totals cover SCRA enforcement generally. The court’s findings in this case concern the state bodies’ coverage under the provision, the permitted scope of screening, and the allegations of a pattern or practice. The Department’s record and the case-specific rulings are therefore different kinds of information.1 For servicemembers and their dependents who think their SCRA rights may have been infringed, the Department directs them to contact the nearest Armed Forces Legal Assistance Program Office. That guidance is broader than the New Mexico bar dispute and is presented as a route for people who believe their rights were violated. The Department’s account does not give a number of inquiries, complaints or applicants connected to this case. It also does not state what further outcome the litigation will produce.1
History
How it came to this- November 19Dismissal motions deniedJudge Kea Riggs rejected motions from the New Mexico Supreme Court and the New Mexico Board of Bar Examiners.
- NowDenied DOJ motions to dismiss denied in New Mexico SCRA licensing case
Impact
Spreading outward, level by level- Level 1Case proceedings
The denial leaves the Department able to continue pursuing its allegations that New Mexico’s licensing practices violate the SCRA.
Analysis - Level 2Who the portability rule covers
The court found that the New Mexico Supreme Court and the Board of Bar Examiners fall within the SCRA provision’s category of licensing authorities.1
Fact - Level 3Permitted screening
A criminal background check may be conducted, but the court said the broader character-and-fitness review normally used for first-time applicants is not permitted in this setting.1
Fact - Level 4Potential effects on bar admissions
If the court’s view of the limits on expansive evaluations is upheld, New Mexico may need to revise its bar admission procedures for military applicants.
Analysis
Sources
What each source supportsWritten by AI from the sources listed below: every fact was checked word for word against its source, and inference is marked apart. How we write